When
comparing the relative merits of the limited liability company
(LLC) and corporation,
simplicity/low cost and
tax
implications can be determining factors in
choosing
the organizational form for your business. State formation
renewal fees are also an important consideration.
State
fees to form an LLC are usually lower than the fees charged
to form a corporation.
|
In Connecticut, the corporate fees are $275 for
formation and $85 for annual renewal, while the LLC fees
are only $60 and $10, respectively.
Similarly, in Rhode Island, the corporate fees are
$150 for formation and $85 for annual renewal, while the
LLC fees are only $50 and $10, respectively.
The fee structure in Connecticut and Rhode Island is
consistent with the intent of LLC law, which, in part,
is to make the LLC a lower-cost alternative to the
corporation.
See our
table comparing the fees charged by each state for
forming an LLC and a corporation. |
|
However, this is not always the case. Some states charge fees
for forming and renewing an LLC that are significantly higher
than what is charged for a corporation. These states seem to
have completely distorted what is supposed to be a principal
advantage of the LLC over the corporation--low cost of formation
and operation. Nevertheless, it is the law.
|
In Massachusetts, the fees for forming and renewing
(annually) a corporation are $200 and $85 respectively,
while for an LLC, there is a $500 formation fee and
a $500 annual renewal fee. |
|
In any event, in most states, the fees charged for the
LLC are lower than those charged for a corporation. Further, in
Delaware and Nevada, two key states for business formation, the
fees charged by the state are the same for the formation of a
corporation and an LLC ($50 in Delaware, and $125 in Nevada).
If you live in one of the states that charge higher fees for
forming and renewing an LLC than a corporation, you may want to
consider forming a corporation, rather than an LLC, at least
where fees are an important deciding factor. However, the fee
savings may be misleading.
The small business owner intending on forming a corporation
should usually form it as a
statutory
close corporation. However, this form is not legally
recognized in Massachusetts and some other states that charge
high LLC fees. So, the fee for forming the statutory close
corporation out of state, plus the fee for registering the
corporation in the home state or wherever it will be doing
business, will probably be equivalent to the fee charged by the
home state for an LLC there.
Special Publication Fees.
While the small business owner should consider that other
factors may, in fact, be more important than the relative fees
charged, nevertheless, special note should be made of
publication fees that three specific states charge when an LLC
is formed or when a foreign LLC is registered.
New York, Pennsylvania and Arizona require that an LLC
publish the information from its
articles
of organization in a newspaper. For example, in New York,
this information must be published once per week, for a total of
six weeks, in two different newspapers. This can cost anywhere
from $1,000 to $2,000, and this may make the LLC a
cost-prohibitive option in these states.
Similarly, any out-of-state LLC that will be doing business
in one of these states must satisfy the same publication
requirements, with information from its registration. This cost
can be expected to be in the same range, as described above.
|
Work Smart
When a small business will be formed in one of these
states, or will be formed out of state, but will be
doing business in one of these states, consideration
should be given to forming a statutory close
corporation, as opposed to an LLC. At the very least,
the small business owner who intends on using an LLC in
one of these states should first attempt to gauge the
cost of publication, by contacting state officials,
before the entity is formed or registered to do business
in the state. |
|
|